My Suicide . . . Then and Now.
I was feeling so low last night that even though I still had a pile of research papers to finish grading I to go surfing. So I did; for about 45 minutes. I went to Scotchman’s, 1-3ft. and bumpy on a tide that was a bit too high for such a weak swell. Still, it was fun. Sammy was there, freaking me out with his fish-breath and long whiskers. I think he lifts that fin out of the water on purpose, pretending he’s a shark. It was good. I managed to connect a few all the way to the shore, but I had to go before I really got all the demons exorcised, and they are still with me.
That morning our Men’s Breakfast Group at church finished our discussion of Viktor Frankl’s
Modern Man’s Search for Meaning. We were discussing Frankl’s Logotherapy, and I revealed a bit too much about myself and my current trauma. One of the men asked if I was “suicidal.” I brushed this off, protesting that I could never do that to my kids.
But, of course, I am suicidal. But I’ve been suicidal before, and I’m still here, more evidence of my inability to see a project through to its conclusion.
I was “really” suicidal when I was seventeen. I was filled with self-loathing and I thought about killing myself almost every day. I would sit in the bathroom with a knife in my hand wondering if I could just slit my wrists and see what would happen. But then, as now, concerns over the effect this would have on others prompted me to stay alive. This seems different than what some suicide-attempters tell me—that they believe everyone would be better off without them—so perhaps, even then, I was unusual.
That self-loathing, and those suicidal tendencies seem like they could be treated with the kind of psychology Freud and Adler proposed. As Frankl characterizes their approaches, Freud and Adler seek the etiology of a neurosis, and seek, by uncovering it, to help the patient overcome it. When I was seventeen I loathed myself because I felt my father loathed me. I felt my religious leaders loathed me. I adopted their perspective of me and chose to join them in hating me. It was the hopelessness of ever being able to live up to those expectations that drove me to want to kill myself.
But now my suicidal tendencies are different. Clearly, the most central emotion in my life is self-hatred. I hate myself. I want to harm myself. At least two dozen times a day I feel like, and visualize, taking a red-hot poker and jamming it through my eye. In my imagination I sink it into my brain which melts and flows out my ears and nose. This is my most real, my most visceral, and my most abiding desire. And I do think about killing myself. I think about it every day. I’ve been thinking about it every day for at least two years—ever since I decided to pursue ordination—and I suspect I will think about it every day as long as I’m working in a church. But now, unlike when I was seventeen, I know that I will not do it. I love my children and I know killing myself would harm them so much that I could never bring myself to do it.
And here the differences between my teen-suicide obsession and my current self-destructive fantasies become more pronounced. If I didn’t have children, I wouldn’t kill myself, because then I could just escape my life. I could quite my job at the church and resume living the kind of life I want to live. I could start doing the things I want to do. I could read poetry again. I could read magazines again. I could listen to music again. I could go camping and hiking and swimming with my kids again . . . oh wait, I don’t have kids in this fantasy. But I can’t do any of those things any more. I have ruined my life, and that is why I think about ending it every day.
Don’t misunderstand me. It is not my kids which motivate my despair; it’s my job, my situation, my identity, that motivates it. If I could leave my job, I wouldn’t be so depressed, but because I have all these kids, I can’t leave my job.
When I worked construction we talked about having some “fuck-you money” stowed away. Fuck-you money is money you keep so that if the boss, or the landlord, or the neighbors get to be too much, you can say, “fuck you” and take off. I have money in the bank, but not nearly enough for a man with four kids to be able to say “fuck you” to anyone, so I swallow it all. I say as little as possible. I choke on my words. I suppress all my feelings.
I also hate myself in a different way now. When I was seventeen I hated myself because I believed I was hate-able. But now I hate myself because I believe in my potential and worth, and I believe I have betrayed all that. Instead of taking a low-paying, but career-building job at the University of Nevada, I took the job at Saint Michael & All Angels and ruined my career. What’s worse, this was clearly an act of self-betrayal, even at the time. When they first offered me the job, even the thought of saying, “yes” to Saint Michael’s made stomach wind up in knots. I knew, my stomach knew, that I was not the right person for the job. I knew, from my experience working in churches, that this kind of job would kill me. I knew it, but for a more comfortable salary—a salary no longer even that comfortable—I betrayed myself, my career, my desires, and my ambitions. I ruined my life.
I certainly wasted it. I wasted all the time, effort, and money I (actually, my wife and I) had put into my education. Nine years of graduate school flushed down the toilet. Now, five years later, no university will touch me. I’m the fucking idiot who’s finished his dissertation five years ago and has, in the words of one of my former teachers, “been teaching Sunday School” for five years. Nobody wants me, and they are right not to want me. I have not kept up with my field the way I should have, and I have published very little. Plus, and I don’t know if anybody can tell, but I am getting stupider and stupider with every month. I’ve been working at Saint Michael & All Angles for sixty months now, and if I’ve just lost one I.Q. point per month, imagine how stupid I am now.
And I continue to betray myself. Since my friend, and assistant, Sam left, I am not myself around anyone. I cannot be myself. I am not even sure who or what that self would be anymore. I don’t do anything that I find interesting or meaningful. I just go through the motions.
I know, all jobs have a down side, and most are rather boring, and believe me, I have had plenty of them, but they are not like this. When you work for a church you are not just doing a job, you are being a person. Yes, in this day and age, you are seen as a service-provider, but you are never just evaluated on the service you provide, you are always forced to be a certain kind of person. Plus, you have to take this job home with you. You have to fret and worry about it.
Besides, do I have to justify the feeling in my stomach? I’m not exaggerating. I feel nauseous every time I drive towards the church. Saturdays are horrible, even worse than Sundays. I wake up Saturday morning feeling ill. I feel like I’m being smothered. By 8:00 p.m. Saturday night I can hardly breathe. Sunday is coming. Sunday is descending on me like some flesh-eating virus.
My “supporters” wonder why I can’t just get ordained and be happy with this work, but I don’t see any of them lining up. The thought of being an ordained minister makes me want to scream. Sometimes I do scream when I think about it, when I’m alone, when I’m where nobody will hear, I scream, and scream. Driving to my seminary class last fall I would scream in the car. I would scream on the way there, and scream on the way home. Does anybody care that this is not the kind of person I want to be? Does anybody care? Apparently not. This is the only job for which I can find employment, the one job that disgusts me the most.
It’s not just the complainers. Saint Michael’s has few of them. Barbara thinks this is all about some vile woman who called me up and chewed me out last Sunday, but it’s not. I know this particular woman is vile, and I evaluate her comments as coming from a vile person. No, it’s not the people. THE PEOPLE AND SAINT MICHAEL & ALL ANGLES ARE WONDERFUL.
No, it’s that I hate everything I do. I don’t feel like the church is really benefiting from me. I don’t feel good about them paying for it. Sure I work hard, but nothing I do there makes any real difference. Yet, if I quit, I won’t be able to pay my rent, and then I’d really hate myself for betraying my family.
So I betray myself.
Now, I’ll tell you a really sick secret. I can tell you, because you are not reading this. Nobody would read such a long blog entry if it wasn’t full of either sex, or right-wing diatribes. Still, I write it here instead of in my journal, because it is possible that it might be read, even though it won't, and so, somehow, this makes it feel like a prayer. Here it goes. . .
Wednesday night, after another soul-crushing (only for me) church event—a dinner for the children’s choir (maybe I’ll tell you later why it was so soul-crushing for me)—I was really filled with self-hatred, images of hot pokers plunging into my skull filled my imagination. My solution? I pulled an exacto-knife out and a lighter, and “sterilized” the blade. Then I made several, seven to be exact, incisions in my left forearm. The pain, the blood, brought me some real relief. Yes, I know, cutting yourself is so adolescent-girl-interrupted-chic . . . a total cliché, but . . .it worked! It not only helped my emotional intensity level drop enough so that I could grade some papers and get some sleep, it sustained me through most of Thursday. My arm hurt all day yesterday, and I didn’t feel like bashing my face in with a brick until about 4:00 p.m.
And now you know why, by 5:00 p.m. yesterday, I just had to go surfing, even in such crummy conditions.